PDA

Archiv verlassen und diese Seite im Standarddesign anzeigen : Which dresswatch would ou choose ...


unknown
20.02.2007, 20:16
Those are imo 2 superb watches and I don't know which one I would take (if I could)
I think I would choose the Journe but I'm not sure

Which one would you take and WHY ??

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y145/unknown100/RL.jpg

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y145/unknown100/FPJ1.jpg

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y145/unknown100/FPJ2.jpg

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y145/unknown100/FPJ3.jpg

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y145/unknown100/FPJ4.jpg
PatrickS
20.02.2007, 20:19
Only speaking about optical attributes I'd prefer the lange. It seems smaller and more elegant to me. I am also not a big fan of blue...

<-- more the classic guy
unknown
20.02.2007, 20:20
it's almost the same size

If I remember correct, the Lange is 40.5 mm and the Journe is 40 mm
slimshady
20.02.2007, 20:21
go for the "lange" mate !!
flost389
20.02.2007, 20:21
lange !!!
Tuxi
20.02.2007, 20:23
Lange, go for It!
Oyster-Day
20.02.2007, 21:00
Lange =)
maawaa
20.02.2007, 21:02
F.P. Journe : :gut:

but...

Lange : :verneig: :verneig: :verneig:
Moehf
20.02.2007, 21:04
Nimm die LANGE!
lightmyfire
20.02.2007, 21:41
Lange....=)
Smile
20.02.2007, 22:20
journe of course -- wonderful 'french' look ... the lange looks like a german tank ... :D
tommsen
20.02.2007, 22:22
lange! ;)
Armando
20.02.2007, 23:11
not easy to decide :grb:

but the Lange looks more classic - go for it :gut:
unknown
21.02.2007, 08:04
is this German chauvinism ??
I do like both but I expected a more equal score ...
If I would have asked the same question on a French site the majority would have answered Journe, right ... ;)

Anyway, like said I admire both but isn't the Journe not more special because it's more rare and the man FP Journe is known as one of the baes watchmakers today (some do compare hem with the person Breguet 250 years ago)
fliplock_frans
21.02.2007, 11:02
I´m Austrian, but still, would go for Lange. nodoubt :cool:

@Smile: If tanks looked like that, i would love war :op:
Sunrider
21.02.2007, 11:12
Lange. Go for it :]
Bergmann
21.02.2007, 15:18
Ich finde die Ziffern 7 und 8 der Journe hässlich. Erstens umgedreht, zweitens kleiner als die anderen Ziffern. :(

Die Lange wirkt eleganter, da das Zb konservativer gehalten ist und nicht so verspielt.

Wenn man römische Ziffern mag, dann die Lange.
miboroco
21.02.2007, 17:15
Original von Tuxi
Lange, go for It!

:gut:
Unruhstifter
21.02.2007, 21:19
Original von Bergmann
Ich finde die Ziffern 7 und 8 der Journe hässlich. Erstens umgedreht, zweitens kleiner als die anderen Ziffern. :(

Tatsache, sehe ich jetzt erst.

Das geht ja gar nicht.

Obwohl Journe nette Teile macht. Aber das Gehäuse der Lange ist schöner, obwohl ich mich an Zentralsekunden bei Lange erst gewöhnen muß.

Gruß Thorsten
Mawal
21.02.2007, 21:52
none of the above...I would settle for PP Calatrava
Donluigi
21.02.2007, 22:03
Me too :gut:
4rolex4me
21.02.2007, 22:09
Lange! Check the Huber SE Lange, that's a real beauty and quite limited!!
JoachimD
22.02.2007, 12:09
Lange:
The dial is elegant and balanced. :gut:
The movement is top notch with in house spring :gut:.
The RL is the PERFECT dress watch.
No other watch gets close the RL.
Not even my L1MP, I have to admit... =(

Joachim
Martini
22.02.2007, 12:15
lange fehlt leider etwas entscheidendes für diese preisklasse: charakter
JoachimD
22.02.2007, 13:51
Original von Martini
lange fehlt leider etwas entscheidendes für diese preisklasse: charakter


:grb:
fliplock_frans
22.02.2007, 14:01
Original von Martini
lange fehlt leider etwas entscheidendes für diese preisklasse: charakter

Der ist auch vom Träger zu ergänzen :D
JoachimD
22.02.2007, 14:09
Original von fliplock_frans

Original von Martini
lange fehlt leider etwas entscheidendes für diese preisklasse: charakter

Der ist auch vom Träger zu ergänzen :D

:gut:

Joachim
klobi
22.02.2007, 14:44
Lange. :jump: :jump: :jump:
Decent design yet great proportions, along with perfect finish and - obviousely - the more prestigious name.

Best regards,
unknown
22.02.2007, 20:27
Original von klobi
Lange. :jump: :jump: :jump:
Decent design yet great proportions, along with perfect finish and - obviousely - the more prestigious name.

Best regards,

I doesn't need to be prestigious ...
But on the other hand I think most WIS will say that a Journe is more prestigious.

Ofcourse both are great but imo there is more 'passion' in a Journe
Milgauss
22.02.2007, 20:46
Lange Lange Lange Lange!!! ;)
simon
22.02.2007, 23:08
No question, I would take the Lange.
It is by far more old school, just like a decent dress watch should be.

Things I rather dislike about F.P.Journe are for example that the letters of the company's logo are way to large, furthermore, I think that the hands look like a disaster and worst of all is that the numerals are of a different size.

The case and the movement, however, look fairly great.